Book Group: Old Man’s War by John Scalzi

[cathschaffstump]

Let’s try to get this squeezed in before Live Journal goes down for the day!

Last night’s book group discussion centered around Old Man’s War by John Scalzi. The group consensus was that the book was a very good read, and we enjoyed the way the book was a homage to Heinlein in structure and in plot. While we nitpicked a bit (ending was a bit thin, some said; others suggested it was a little wistful and maudlin; sure, your wife’s clone would be the one to rescue you; differentiation of minor characters was meh), overall, we had many good things to say.

Group We (TM) really enjoyed the idea of adventuring after 75. Group We (TM) also felt that the examination of alien life forms as something, well, alien, was worthwhile, as opposed to the Star Trek tactic of gluing a handle on the nose of a biped, and then you’re done. Group We thought the plot was well paced, the science was plausible, and the humor was worthwhile.

The book also stimulated us to discuss issues: were the soldiers really themselves, or copies of themselves, and what does it mean to be a self? What are the ethics of war? What are the ethics of interaction with other species? We didn’t come to any conclusions, because the book is good enough to support several interpretations of answers to these questions. Thus, the literature teacher was happy.

Overall, Group We recommends Old Man’s War, and we hope to read further books which discuss and muddy these issues. Well done, Scalzi.

***

Next month, we meet December 15th. Don’t forget to bring two things: Your gift book (inspiring or white elephant, wrapped to maintain mystery) and your short stories (no more than 50 pages total) for people to get a jump start for reading in February.

Jim Hines’ Goblin Quest is our next read. Expect some D&D parody action! Jim, we should get you added to the reading group list very shortly.

Catherine

Originally published at Writer Tamago. You can comment here or there.

Comments

[frankieb-sq87.livejournal.com]

I am so glad to see you enjoyed the book. I know it's silly. . . but I get a huge kick out of anyone reading anything of his. :-D

[manzabar.livejournal.com]

That's not silly. It always feels good when others agree. It kind of validates/reinforces our own opinions.

Caveat: I was at this discussion. I picked the book for the discussion. And I was once told I'd "out-stalked" another fan at a reading Scalzi gave. Just to try and make that sound slightly less creepy, all I did was remember he liked Coke Zero vs. regular Coke.

[cathschaffstump.livejournal.com]

BTW, Mark is not creepy in any way, and totally friendable, if you need a Scalzi friend. He is the template for Milo.

Mark, Frankie once told me that I was her favorite author. I don't know if that's still true, but she's wonderful. I met her at a Renn Faire a couple of years ago.

One of the great pleasures of my life is introducing good people to other good people.

:)

Catherine